Stationary Tensioner Belt Design

I am trying to create a belt with a non-rotating tensioner (see attached image). The tensioner is in a slot to allow for vertical movement but I still get an warning saying one pulley is fixed. After some digging, I realized that it is because the tensioner cannot rotate. Is it possible to engage only certain pulleys or do all pulleys have to rotate? Thanks!

SolidworksAssemblies