Reference Plane Normals

Is it possible to define the normal of a plane?

Why it matters?   A lot of times, I'll define a plane by a 3D sketch with a line and a point.   Then, I'll use that plane for making sketches and parts etc.    Later on, I need to re-define that original plane (as a part has changed).  When I do that, sometimes the normal of that plane 'flips' and all of my sketches are now on the other side of that plane and break, and it's just a huge mess.

Any ideas?

Sam

SolidworksParts And Features
Answers 6
DD
DD 2010-04-26 Best Answer

Unfortunately, no direct control is possible. I hope you can find a way to redefine the 3DSketch to correct the problem.

SF
SF 2010-04-27

Sam,

Turn in an enhancement request.

While you're waiting (I've been waiting for years), you might try working around the problem. An old solution that used to work most of the time (I haven't tried it lately) was to move your sketch to a plane perpendicular to the one you want it on, then back to the one you want. You might have to try it several times. With luck, on one of the tries it will end up facing the right way.

Jerry Steiger

KL
KL 2010-04-27

That's normally what I do, but you could also use the Mirror function (with the copy option off) in the sketch mode.

SF
SF 2010-04-27

Sam,

Kelvin is smarter than I am and knows the easy way to do it!

One reason why I haven't been using the perpendicular plane method much lately is that I always try to make sure that my sketches have as few links to the model as possible. Sketches usually start with two perpendicular lines at the origin or some point on the model. Then as much as possible gets dimensioned off of the lines. That way you can remove one association to the model and then mirror the sketch as Kelvin suggested.

If you have a sketch with a lot of converted edges or offsets from edges or other links to the model, then you're stuck and have to try the perpendicular plane method.

Jerry Steiger

SF
SF 2010-04-27

Thanks for the advice!  I'll put in a request.

Sam

RS
RS 2010-04-27

Yet another thing SW needs to steal from Pro/E!

I've done quire a bit of experimenting in an attempt to control plane normal and sketch horizontal.  Nothing that works consistently.

If I know I'm going to be moving a sketch around, I do away with "vertical" and "horizontal" completely.  I draw a pair of perpendicular construction lines and constrain everything parallel or perpendicular to those.  That way I can drag and rotate a whole sketch without flipping overexternal references.