Inserting Multi-body in new part

I can swear I've done this before with success but for some reason its not working now. I have a part that has 2 extrudes without the merge entities checked (2 bodies). Now I want to have each body as separate parts without any link to each other. When I insert the body in a new part I get a split feature part. My goal is to access the original sketch in the saved body that I've inserted in the new part. How do I do this?

SolidworksParts And Features