Insert into new part doesn't use my part template

I have a part template set as my default. In 2011 and prior, I could create a multi-body part, select a body and click "insert into new part". The new part would be based on the same part template as the original part file.

In 2012, it's exporting things onto one of the Solidworks default templates, completely disregarding my custom template (which is set as my default part template). How can I address this? When exporting a body into its own part, I like having the same set of custom properties to link to in drawings, etc. Additionally, when using our CAM plugin, the units are often not what I've set them up to be.

SolidworksGeneral