Changing the laminate schedule of a composite tube won't change the resonant frequency.

Hello all,

I have been attempting to simulate the resonant frequencies of a composite shaft. So far I have been able to get relatively accurate (<4% offset from experimental) with my "standard" laminate. However, when I adjust ply angles or add/remove plies the simulation states the resonant frequency remains unchanged (IE standard laminate for a shaft with a diameter of 3'' and length of 38'' will give a frequency of x Hz while a shaft with the same dimensions but using a vastly different laminate will give a frequency of x[+/- 2] Hz). Soon I will add a mock-up of my simulation using the same constraints for your convenience. Thank you in advance for your help!

Scott

EDIT:

added files (assembly with referenced parts)

SolidworksSimulation
Answers 4
SF
SF 2015-03-31 Best Answer

do you have a reference that shows what the new frequency should be? maybe +/- 2Hz is correct?

SF
SF 2015-03-31

Yes. I have two reference points. We had tested two shafts (same diameter, wall thickness, and length) with different laminate schedules. The results showed a 15 Hz difference in the resonant frequency. The simulation showed a difference of 0.45 Hz. When working with one laminate, I'm able to accurately predict the resonant frequency but when the laminate is changed all the accuracy is lost. So to answer your question, I know the simulation is giving me poor results, but I'm not sure how or why.

SF
SF 2015-03-31

have you tried setting up a brand new study from scratch with the new laminate profile?

that would confirm that the issue is with the software and not something about the editing of the laminate

SF
SF 2015-04-01

No, I haven't. I'll do that and see if the problem persists. Thanks!