Negative Flory-Huggins parameters in DPD dynamics

Good morning,

I am utilizing computational methods to calculate χFH parameters of flavonoids in some solvents to use as imput to DPD simulations. I did it by calculating the energy of mixing Emix by molecular dynamics of pure and mixed components. Then I would determine the Emix from cohesive energy densities. Most of the χFH parameters that I obtain are negative (the studied molecules are, in fact, miscible in the solvents),

The problem is:

Some of the the values are negative and high in module (example: -12) and in response to that the DPD repulsion parameters (by Groot & Warren’s approach) have a negative sign, which render the results no longer meaningful.

Had anyone parameterised a similar system for DPD using χFH parameters, or could suggest an alternative approach?

Thank you

Best regards

Felipe

Answers 4
RA
RA 2013-07-04

Hi Felipe,

Could you share with us the procedure you have taken to determine the chi parameters? It would seem that a chi parameter value of -12 indicates an unusual affinity of two components. You may want to compare your results with the solubility parameter approach, taking into account only the pure components.

Best,

Reinier

FS
FS 2013-07-05

Hello! Thanks for the reply

I have the intention to study a system of polymer, flavonoids and solvent in the mesoscale.

In this first part I am studying the flavonoid+solvent in the mesoscale.

I am dealing with flavonoids and a series of solvents (acetone, acetonitrile, etc)

I calculated the cohesive energy using the methodology found in Huynh, L.; et al. Pharm.Res. 2008, 25 (1), 147–157.

CED=Ecoh/V = (Evac - Ebulk)*C/V,

where Evac is the energy in vacuum and Ebulk the energy in bulk (both after NPT and NVT dynamics), C a conversion factor (kcal to J) and V the volume of the cell,

I calculated the cohesive energy by the formula:

∆Emix = φa(Ecoh/V)a + φb(Ecoh/V)b - (Ecoh/V)mix

and the Chi (Χ) parameter

Χ = ∆Emix/RT

The solubility parameter approach would be:

Χ = V(δa-δb)^2/RT

With the V = the molar volume of the molecule, correct?

With this approach, the resulting χ, indicates me repulsion of phases with two miscible molecules (experimentally observed), per example.

The parameter for my solvents is in accord with the parameters in literature; In this case I could have something wrong with the solubility parameter calculation for my molecule (quercetin). So I tried to calculate it by Synthia and got a similar value, around 30 (which, I suspect, could be wrong).

Since I have the experimental enthalpy of mixing, I could try to calculate the χ parameter by

ΔHmix = Χ*RT φa* φb

where φ are the volume fraction. But, since some values are negative, it gives me even “higher” negative values.

Thank you for the help

Best regards

Felipe

RA
RA 2013-07-05

Hi Felipe,

Thanks for the details. I think there is a mistake in the method by Huynh (which is found a number of other papers). The relation between the chi parameter and the energy-of-mixing lacks a concentration term:

Χ = V*∆Emix/(RT φa* φb)

This term cancels the concentration dependency in ∆Emix (otherwise Χ would be 0 when φa->0,1). Note also if defining ∆Emix as energy density (as you did), you need to multiply by a reference volume V, corresponding to the bead volume in your DPD model (usually taken to be the average volume of a and b).

So you could obtain Χ by calculating ∆Emix as a function of φa, and fit the data to C*φa*(1-φa), from which Χ = C*V/RT. But it is difficult to obtain ∆Emix accurately when the concentration is low, and the result isn't always successful (for a discussion see J. Chem. Phys. 128, 244904 (2008)).

I believe people had more success with the solubility parameter approach. This is easier (as you don't have to simulate the mixture), albeit less exact (e.g. Χ is always positive).

Still all this doesn't explain the negative values you found, which is odd as one would expect ∆Emix > 0 (as well as Ecoh > 0). How does the experimental enthalpy of mixing compare with the simulated value, ∆Hmix = V*∆Emix+ p*V?

Reinier

FS
FS 2013-07-09

Thanks for the fast reply

I will see the corrections (the lack of a V multiplying the ∆Emix was a typo from my part, thanks for the indication)

and as soon I get to my notes I can make the comparation with the ∆Hmix

But I can say in advance that I cannot compare both in order of magnitude (after converting J/mol to J/g).

The experimental ∆Hmix obtained by calorimetric methods for the flavonoid and tert-amyl alcohol is negative (arround -50 J/g) and flavonoid and flavonoid and acetonitrile is positive (arround 40 J/g) (Chebil, et al industrial & Engineering Chemistry Research 2013 52 (4),1464-1470).

Also I have a question with the Synthia Module, the results I obtain for solubility parameters, molar volume and densities are not in accord with literature vallues for the solvents in this study (acetonitrile and tert-amyl alcohol). For example: The molar volume of acetonitrile, in 298K, should be 52 mol/cm3 and in the Synthia module the value is arround 23,7 mol/cm3.

best regards

Message was edited by: Felipe Azevedo Rios Silva