Binding energies in Discovery Studio 2020

Hi everyone, 

I am a PhD student who is using Discovery Studio 2020 for molecular dockings. My plan was to use binding energies for ranking the poses, although I am not sure the values I got are valid or they are the result of some mistakes or missing steps. The numbers I've got always in the range of 100-500 kcal/mol. 

The steps I did throughout the dockings: preparing the ligands and the protein (except re-building the loops, my protein required an alpha and beta subunit within a chain), using libdock for docking applying the recommended settings (plus adding flexible side chains), in situ ligand minimisation, and calculating binding energies at the end. 

Thanks a lot for any help or suggestions. 

Answers 2
JS
JS 2021-10-11

Hi Anna, you might want to look at the Ligand Interactions command under the View Interactions tool panel to get an idea of the favorable and unfavorable interactions that are happening between your receptor and ligand and this may tell more of a story about the values you are seeing. For example if you have more unfavorable interactions than favorable it may explain why the energy is positive. But in general these values should be used for comparative purposes to help pick the top poses. You may also want to use the Score Ligand Poses protocol as well to find your top poses (or a combination of both results). 

CB
CB 2021-10-12

Hi Anna. When you run the Calculate Binding Energies protocol which Implicit Solvent Model do you use? If you are not already doing so you should run with the GBSW, GBMV or PBSA methods for more rigorous treatment of the solvent. If you are running with the default None (vacuum) option I wonder if the neglect of solvent is contributing to the binding energies being so high.